InTheBite

  • Home
  • News
    • All News
    • Featured Stories
    • General News
    • Captain of the Year
    • Tournament Results
    • First Builds
    • Splash Reports
    • Old Salts Rule
    • Tackle Tips
    • Dock Talk
    • Crew Records
    • Conservation
  • Tournaments
    • Calendar
    • Captain of the Year
    • Champion’s Cup
  • Shop
    • All Products
    • Subscriptions
    • Back Issues
    • Shirts
    • Hats & Visors
    • Miscellaneous
    • Release Rulers
  • Classifieds
  • Job Board
  • Contact
    • Contact InTheBite
    • InTheBite Media Kit
  • Log in

The Billfish Foundation Calls for Balance in U.S. Atlantic Shark Management

January 12, 2022 By InTheBite Digital Editor

The Billfish Foundation, Wednesday, Jan. 12, 2022—The Billfish Foundation (TBF) primarily focuses on billfish and other highly migratory species, including swordfish and tunas. “Sharks do not fall within our primary mission, however the current excessive shark depredation demands that TBF address the problem, otherwise billfish and many other species being killed by sharks, recreational fishing opportunities, and related businesses will continue to be harmed,” the Foundation stated. “Shark predation is out of control and the NMFS has no constructive plan to check it. In no way does TBF condone the finning of live sharks, it is a hideous practice that must be stopped.”

Balance between shark conservation, which has been hugely successful, and management of fisheries, the act of fishing by people, which supports jobs, markets, experiences and economics is needed. Balance is lacking in U.S. Atlantic shark management.

Shark Depredation 

Those fishing know that shark depredation, the taking of angler-hooked fish from all platforms, is occurring at unseen rates and damages gear, ruins fishing experiences and negatively impacts economic returns.  Crews share it is no longer safe to swim between boats, as sometimes needed to help with a problem on a companion vessel.  The only way shark depredation will lessen is for fewer sharks to remain in the water, which could be realized with resurgence of a profitable bottom longline shark fishery and market. 

Federal Solutions to Shark Depredation

In the NOAA/NMFS’ document, SHARE, which reviewed its Atlantic shark management, 3 solutions are offered, all considered essential, to better manage sharks, including addressing  shark depredation: (1) schedule shark identification workshops for captains and anglers, (2) share educational material on how to avoid sharks while fishing – this would be an interesting read, and (3) establishing a recreational shark fishing quota that counts landed shark, released dead and live sharks and, factors in a post-release mortality percentage – this sounds punitive. These solutions offer no help; they merely redirect management’s energy to “busy-type work.”  The intent is honorable, but comes mostly from those who have little to no fishing experience and do not understand fish or fishing dynamics on the water.  Rather than spend a lot of money for contractors to research how to implement the three options, funds might be better used to assess how to increase legal landings of sharks to save that fishery and/or to redirect fishing effort to species not overfished, this is unfortunately a problem. Revitalizing the shark fishery is essential to help alleviate shark depredation.

Shark Finning Bans 

Federal banning of finning of live sharks was important and has huge public support, including that from TBF. The bans collapsed the shark market because fins were the most lucrative product sold ($11.20 per pound). Harvesters then left the fishery. Dealers became uncertain what they could or should sell for even with fins removed from dead sharks remaining legal, public perception would not likely distinguish the fin source. Prices paid for shark products plummeted, all leading to excessive numbers of sharks remaining in the water depredating recreationally hooked fish.  NOAA numbers from 2020 provide the value of the shark fishery is $2.28 million for landing 2.2 million sharks. Those economic numbers do not reflect successful management of the fishery, which includes jobs, people, economics and experiences. Some states followed the federal finning ban by implementing their own. Texas went further and also banned the possession of fins, even though the removal of fins from a dead shark remains legal.  Pending federal legislation proposes to prohibit all sales of fins, even when legally obtained.

“Because federal law requires an annual report be sent to Congress from the federal agencies on the progress to stop shark finning and conservation accomplishments, it is our belief that the requirement elevated sharks to a higher priority with the federal staff members,” TBF states. “This is clear in the fishery management plan for HMS where 7 out of 13 completed plan amendments and an 8th one in draft are for Atlantic sharks.” 

Science – Shark Assessments Questioned

The agency proclaims that its management is based on the “best available science,” which does not mean necessarily the most accurate science, often it means the science that is available. Stock assessments provide the foundation for fishery management decisions.  The assessment methodology and processes (SEDAR) used for Atlantic large coastal and small coastal sharks continue to generate questions about data accuracy and methodologies. Perfection cannot be achieved in assessing numbers of wild animals moving across large expanses of ocean water, but TBF expects the highest standards, methodologies and expertise be used for subsequent decisions impact not only the species, but also people, experiences, jobs and economies. Government funds to improve stock assessment methodologies and processing should be a priority for sharks and all marine fish.  

Recreational Shark Fishery 

In estimating the number of sharks caught by anglers, the government includes in the “total catch”, the number of landed sharks kept, landed sharks discarded dead and landed sharks released alive. Including live releases implies agency staff seem to speculate that angler-released sharks die.  TBF stated it does not accept that speculation as the truth. If a post-release mortality percentage is included, as proposed by the agency, anglers may soon not be able to catch sharks, almost treating all sharks as if listed under the Endangered Species List.

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Email

Do you have any comments or questions for us? We’d love to hear from you.

    Filed Under: Fishing, General News, News Tagged With: billfish foundation, marine conservation, shark population, sharks

    Recent News

    refit

    A Refit Case Study: 2008 61’ Spencer, MJ’s

    Purchasing a 2008 boat in need of updates has its advantages. During a 10-month search to find such a boat was exactly what Michael Yocco and his father Joe accomplished. “Our approach was to find a boat within a certain budget which included the p … [Read More...]

    Innovating the Marlin Weight Formula

    By Dale Wills Anytime I hear someone ask, “How big was the fish?” I’m often reminded of my father and his classic dad joke. Taking his hands from about 12 inches apart and slowly moving them to almost full arms width apart, he would gaze at you wit … [Read More...]

    safety

    Prep and Safety

    By Captain Scott "Fraz" Murie Years ago, back in the ‘80s, there was an old captain who used to tell me “it’s all in the preparation.” That is still true today. It took me a while to understand, but I learned there is a lot of wisdom in those words … [Read More...]

    2022 Cajun Canyons Billfish Classic Winners

    This year's first place title at the 2022 Cajun Canyons Billfish Classic went to Southern Charm, Capt. Landon Bell. Mon Chari, Capt. Matt Coppoletta, took second with Amigo, Capt. Brad Schoenfeld, taking third. Heaviest marlin went to Capt. Erik … [Read More...]

    New Travel Update for The Bahamas

    The Islands of the Bahamas, June 16, 2022—Effective Sunday 19th June 2022 The Bahamas Travel Health Visa (BTHV) will no longer be required to travel to The Bahamas. However, all present COVID-19 Testing, and Vaccination Protocols will remain in e … [Read More...]

    Leave a Reply

    Connect With InTheBite

    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Twitter
    • YouTube

    Subscribe to InTheBite Magazine Today!

    InTheBite Magazine Current Cover

    Our latest issue is hitting the docks now! Be sure to subscribe to the hottest bluewater mag on the market. Purchase or Subscribe »

    InTheBite Champion’s Cup

    InTheBite Champions Cup Logo

    New for 2022, the Champion’s Cup is an optional paid entry with a winner-takes-all prize format for teams who want to up the stakes in each division utilizing our longstanding tournament scoring formula.

    Captain of the Year Cup Standings

    COTY / ITB Cup Logo

    News

    • New Travel Update for The Bahamas

      New Travel Update for The Bahamas

      The Islands of the Bahamas, June 16, 2022—Effective Sunday 19th June 2022 The Bahamas Travel Health Visa (BTHV) will no longer be required to travel to The Bahamas. However, all present COVID-19 Testing, and Vaccination Protocols will remain in effect and will need to be presented at check-in. [Read More...]

    • It Just Takes Time Three-Peats as 2022 MGCBC Champion

      It Just Takes Time Three-Peats as 2022 MGCBC Champion

      June 13, 2022; Biloxi, Mississippi—Owner/angler Nick Pratt, Capt. Chris Hood and the It Just Takes Time team swept the blue marlin divisions by weighing the only qualifier during the 2022 Mississippi Gulf Coast Billfish Classic, which concluded Sunday, June 12. The 763.6-pound blue gave the team an unprecedented win for the third year in a row. That feat has never been accomplished... [Read More...]

    • 2022 Georgetown Blue Marlin Tournament Results

      2022 Georgetown Blue Marlin Tournament Results

      Jay Weaver, captain of the Blue Sky, seized first place in the 54th annual Georgetown Blue Marlin tournament, which ran from May 26 to May 28. No fewer than 71 boats participated in the event, the largest turnout since 2000, according to Tournament Coordinator Amy Dukes. The Blue Sky caught and released three blue marlins and one sailfish, while Capt. Stuart... [Read More...]

    • Old No. 7 Wins the Inaugural Florida Sailfish Cup

      Old No. 7 Wins the Inaugural Florida Sailfish Cup

      Florida Sailfish Cup, June 3, 2022—After seven months of fishing, the first annual Florida Sailfish Cup has come to a close. 41 boats participated in the tournament and represented all different locations over Florida, from New Smyrna Beach all the way to Key West, FL. 183 Sailfish were released between the top three teams across their five fishing days and... [Read More...]

    • Quantified, Skin Deep Take First at Gulf Coast Masters

      Quantified, Skin Deep Take First at Gulf Coast Masters

      First place release at the 2022 Gulf Coast Masters went to the Quantified with Capt. Justin Drummond at the helm. Second place release went to Bandito, Capt. Bobby Wade, with third place release going to Mollie, Capt. Jeff Shoults. Capt. Kyle Smith and the Skin Deep team took first place for their 702-pound blue marlin. [Read More...]

    Search InTheBite

    Copyright © 2022 InTheBite, LLC · All Rights Reserved.

    loading Cancel
    Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
    Email check failed, please try again
    Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.